4 out of 5 stars
Halloween Bingo 2026
I read this for the A Grimm Tale square of my 2026 Halloween Bingo card.
This past summer, I reread The Odyssey. Now I kind of wish that I had also revisited The Iliad. This novel is set at the very beginning of the Trojan war. Mostly, when I think about this war, I think about the Trojan Horse, the great wooden horse which the Greeks used to sneak into the city of Troy. If Wikipedia can be believed, it is only briefly mentioned in The Odyssey, but receives fuller treatment in The Aeneid. I hadn't thought about it, but this event was at the end of a years long bloody war. Gemmell writes a gripping tale of this mythic event.
I was interested to compare Homer's version of Odysseus with Gemmell's. Homer depicts him as crafty, brave, and eloquent. Gemmell gives him the epithet the Ugly One and emphasizes his ability to spin heroic tales out of unfortunate events.
Despite my weariness with fantasy world battles, Gemmell roped me in with characters I truly cared about. I was once again pleasantly surprised by the significance of the women. Andromache is shown to be a woman of courage and intelligence. Kalliope is more impetuous but proves to be loyal and tough. Gemmell also creates two men who guide the reader through the Greek world which is unfamiliar to many of us. Kalliades and Banokles provided me with their viewpoints to all the action. They are sword brothers, but they couldn't be more different. Kalliades is a planner, intelligent and sensitive. Banokles is ruled by his desires for food, wine, and women. Late in the book, watching Banokles in charge of other men and watching him bumble his way to heroism was highly entertaining.
Some men are not brave or tough, some women have immense courage. Gemmell gives us real feeling characters that we can cheer for and sympathize with. Since characters are the way to this reader's heart, this book was a success for me. I'll look forward to the third volume.







